What sort of Economy?  What sort of working class? (3 of 5)

Many of these international developments not unexpectedly find reflection in Ireland, often in an exaggerated fashion.  Falling labour shares are associated with more open and liberalised capitalist economies and the economy of the Irish State has one of the most globalised in the world. (23) It no longer has the pretence to an independent currency (it never had one), can no longer set its own interest rates and progressively removed capital controls over the 1980s and 1990s. (24)

The share of expenditure going towards social protection as a share of GDP in the EU 15 rose slightly from 26.1% in 1991 to 27.9% in 2002 while it fell from 19.6% to 16% in the Irish State.  The adjusted wage share of the economy which fell in the EU15 (see above), fell more dramatically in the Irish State – from 77.9% in the period 1960 – 1970 to 54% in 2001 – 2007.  The share of non-agricultural incomes going to capitalists, the self-employed and landlords rose from 30.7% in 1987 to 48.1% in 2004 while the share of wages, pensions and social security fell from 69.2% to 52.1% in the same period. (25)  This growing polarisation is reflected in increasing inequality.  Between 1994-95 and 1999-2000 the average gross disposable income of the lowest 10% grew by 33.3% while it rose by 54.8% for the 6th highest and by 61.8% for the highest (richest) 10% of households. (26) [Most of these figures, because of their use of GDP, are distorted by US multinationals recording economic activity in the Irish state purely for tax purposes.  This has led to the employment of different measures in order to exclude this effect.]

The processes lying behind these shifts include a growth in atypical employment and migration of workers into the State. (27)  GAMA and Irish Ferries are testament to the use of foreign workers to lower particular and overall pay rates.  The union bureaucracy has failed to fight this and often collaborated with it.  Like unions elsewhere the Irish trade union movement has been weakened over the years despite growth in absolute numbers which it could hardly fail to achieve given the enormous rise in the workforce including in the public sector.  However, its policy of not seeking to organise in the multinational sector and the emulation of this by indigenous private sector bosses has seen union density also fall.  There are various measures but all show decline.(28)

Across the world, including Ireland the ability and willingness of the working class to fight back in defence of its interests has undoubtedly been set back.  Strike statistics are only the most graphical measure of this development.  Taking 42 countries and looking at the period between 1981-85 and 1996-2000 the number of countries in which strikes increased was 8 while there were 34 countries in which they declined.  In the group in which strikes rose the increase was only 5,183 while the reduction in strike numbers was 63,657 in the group of countries in which there was a decline.(29)  In the Irish State the annual number of days lost in strikes has fallen from over 580,000 in the 1970s to 26,650 in 2005.  In the latter year there were only 15 strikes and only 10 in 2006, in which only 7,352 working days were lost, the lowest since records began in 1923.(30)

Industry & Workers

In looking at the future the only guide we have is the past, and the conceptual tools to analyse it in order to make some more or less tentative judgements.  While the globalisation of capitalism is not a completely new phenomenon it is nonetheless true that the wave of internationalisation of capital has built upon earlier development and has reached a new level.  It has brought huge countries more fully, into the dynamics of capitalist accumulation.  In doing so it has created new working classes.  The growth of the Irish working class is a small part of this process.  Marx believed the development of capitalism will bring its gravediggers, but the new wave of capitalist growth takes place not just after a series of important defeats of the working class but also in historically new circumstances, in which the idea of a socialist alternative has hardly been weaker than for well over 100 years.  The recent general election has confirmed the marginal character of the left in Ireland. [This has only changed slightly in recent years with the election of a small number of left TDs, the total of which has tended to decline, and without any comparable increase in its social weight.]

Historically geographical shifts in industrial production have created new working classes and, after a period, new class struggles.  The paradigmatic industry of the twentieth century was the car industry.  In fact, so emblematic has it been to successive waves of industrialisation that it has given its name to the way some theorists characterise the whole capitalist economy, speaking of ‘Fordism’ and ‘post-Fordist’ economies.  The mass car industry has grown and shifted production from the US in the 1920s and 1930s, to north-west Europe after the Second World War, to southern Europe, including Argentina, then Brazil and South Africa mainly in the 1970s, and then South Korea in the 1980s and 1990s.

Much of this movement was designed to avoid unionisation or to seek out lower wages.  The original decision to site auto production in Detroit was because of its anti-union environment and plants were almost immediately opened elsewhere after the big car factory strikes in 1936, in Buffalo in 1937 and in the US south and in rural areas.  In Brazil investment dried up from the mid-1980s to mid-1990s after widespread strikes, and when it resumed it went to new greenfield sites devoid of unions.(31)  In South Africa the failure to destroy militant unions was one factor leading to disinvestment in the 1980s.  In Korea there were new class struggles although even here a new militant working class could not escape world –wide trends of reduced militancy, strikes fell from a high of 3,749 in 1987 to only 78 in 1997 before slowly increasing to 320 in 2003.(32) Nevertheless the shift in production from one site to another inevitably brought struggle in its wake even if this took some time – after all it took US unions 38 years to organise in Ford. (33)

The pace of events has quickened so that struggles arise earlier and unionisation sooner, but so also does incorporation and bureaucratisation of trade union movements.  In part this reflects the product cycle: the car industry is no longer a new one with surplus profits from which workers may gain some portion.  Production therefore continues to shift, in the US to small towns around the great lakes.(34)  The search for increased exploitation takes place under ‘lean production’ strategies that are often ‘lean and mean.’

This experience of the car industry found a parallel in the ‘leading’ industry of the 19th century – textiles.  It too saw production progressively mechanised and spread across the world from one country to another.  The last few decades have witnessed the decimation of the textile industry in Ireland – north and south – beaten by low wage competition from abroad.  Even more so than cars the textile industry is a mature one, even with technological progress in fashion and materials, so the scope for gains by workers in new production sites may be more limited.  Today it is thought that car production, with its large numbers of workers brought together under one roof, is particularly suited to organisation, in contrast to textile production units, which have typically been much smaller and staffed more by women.  In fact, the introduction of mechanisation in the car industry including the conveyor belt was also initially thought to be inimical to working class organisation – undermining the bargaining power acquired through possession of craft skills and reflecting ethnic divisions inside the workforce.  It should also not be forgotten that one of working class history’s greatest bearers of struggle have been miners who have often worked in relatively small workplaces and with technology that has deskilled many of them. (35)

Thus, just as industrialisation shifted its driving edge from one industry to another so did worker organisation shift from one industry to another.  While it may appear that car workers had greater bargaining power than textile workers it has been argued that the latter were no less militant, perhaps more so, but that their struggles were much more likely to go down to defeat. (36) And this brings us to the key variable in working class organisation and militancy.  New developments in industrial organisation such as geographical dispersion of production and ‘just-in-time’ management have left capitalism more vulnerable to action by workers in the transport industries, and particularly new ones such as aviation.  Yet today’s transport workers do not display comparably more militancy than those of yesteryear.  What matters most then is not any objective bargaining power, derived either through possession of scarce skills or size and nature of the workplace. What matters is the political context and political consciousness.

This can be seen in the history of workers in the industries we have mentioned.  It is seen in the militancy of textile workers despite their relatively unfavourable bargaining position.  It can be seen in the car industry where in 1930s America political workers were crucial to strikes.  In France the main Renault plant in Paris was closed for the first time in 20 years by the May Day strike in 1936.  In contrast it can be seen negatively in the experience of workers in the aviation industry today.

The modern industries that play the leading role in capitalist accumulation are now also held to be inimical to easy organisation.  Firstly, it is hard to identify just what the early 21st century equivalent to the textile or car industry is.  Computerisation is driving technological development, and the semiconductor industry is obviously central to this, but it employs relatively few people and has not had the wider impact on working class development of these earlier industries.  Many service industries seem either to combine very well paid workers, including for example some finance professionals, with much lower status and lower paid workers such as secretaries, telephone operators, cleaners and porters.  There is no reason not to assume the proletarianisation of much of the former but this has yet to happen on a widespread basis.  Personal services employ workers with relatively weak workplace and market place bargaining power but none of these obstacles are insuperable to organisation and militancy, especially with wider community support and mobilisation, i.e. when their struggles start to take on political characteristics. (37)

In any case we should emphasise that successful organisation for socialists is not primarily about achieving permanent gains within the system but organising for its abolition.  The victories won by US car workers were subverted by the ‘Treaty of Detroit’ leading to the incorporation of US unions into the cold war establishment consensus, joining the witch hunt of militants, defeating rank and file organisation, accommodating to discriminatory practices and presiding over both membership decline and job losses. (38)  Permanent victories, as Connolly once put it, do not exist short of the final victory, and this is not a trade union task. (39)

Notes:

(23) It has been voted the most globalised state in the world three years in a row by the US ‘Foreign Policy’ magazine.

(24) See ‘Financial Liberalisation and Economic Growth in Ireland’, John Kelly and Mary Everett, Central Bank Quarterly Bulletin Autumn 2004.

(25) Quoted in K Allen, op cit, pp. 244 & 245.

(26) R Munck, ‘Social Class and Inequality’, in ‘Contemporary Ireland: A Sociological Map’, p. 307 edited S O’Sullivan.  See also the tables in ‘Bust to Boom: the Irish experience of growth and inequality’, Edited by B Nolan, P O’Connell and C Whelan, p,130 and 131 which suggest inequality driven by the rich getting richer.

(27) For example part time work increased from 10% of the total in 1990 to 18.1% in 2003, ‘Economic Miracles’, op cit p. 12.

(28) As a percentage of the employed workforce trade union membership has fallen from 56.2% in 1987 to 42% in 1998, quoted in ‘Corporatism in Ireland: a view from below’, in ‘Irish Employment Relations in the New Economy’, D D’Art and T Turner, p. 271. Separate figures record a reduction from 46% in 1994 to 35% in 2004 while ICTU admits that density has fallen from 39% to 36% in the last three years. It is lowest among young workers and is only 17.7% in those under 24 years of age.  Where unions exist member participation has dropped.

(29) Quoted in ‘Global Industrial Relations’ edited by Morley, Gunnigle and Collings, p 279.

(30) Labour Relations Commission.

(31) Strike activity in Brazil reached a peak of 9 million workers involved in 1987.  During the four years from 1985 to 1988, real industrial wages in Greater Sao Paulo grew by an average of 10 percent per year.’ B J Silver Forces of Labour: Workers’ Movements and Globalisation since 1870’ p. 36.

(32) ‘Global Industrial Relations,’ op cit.

(33) The exception, it is pointed out, is Japan where the working class suffered an historic defeat before the rise of mass car production.  B J Silver, op cit.

(34) Japanese car factories have also moved to small towns close to the heart of traditional car manufacturing in the US and have avoided unionisation in the process.  In Europe they have done the next best thing and signed single union sweetheart deals. ‘Global Restructuring and the Power of Labour’, Bill Dunn, p. 74

(35) The construction industry has also been one where subcontracting and small firm size did not prevent relatively high levels of unionisation although the scale of the former has increased, for example the percentage of UK construction workers directly employed fell from 77% in 1976 to 45% in 1996. Bill Dunn, op. cit., p. 108.

(36) In B J Silver, op cit.

(37) Call centres have actually grouped finance workers into larger workplaces even as the number and size of bank branches decline.  They have been described as the ‘dark satanic mills’ of the 21st century.  There are examples of workers fighting back against their bosses in the finance industry.  In Spain bosses’ attempts to reduce the workforce ‘found that dismissals are problematic and costly, because voluntary redundancy is close to nonexistent and labor unions are strong and disputatious’.  In France ‘by occupying their workplace, workers succeeded in forcing Société Générale to abandon a plan to eliminate jobs.’ Bill Dunn, p. 159.

(38) There were job cuts of 75,000 between 1957 and 1963. ‘Global Restructuring and the Power of Labour’, Bill Dunn, p. 67.

(39) These struggles were characterised by Rosa Luxemburg as a ‘labour of Sisyphus.’

Back to part 2

What sort of Economy?  What sort of working class? (2 of 5)

It is a commonplace that the Irish State has benefited from globalisation and the processes associated with it.  This includes the development of the EU with its transfer of subsidies to offset increased competition with domestic capital and the wave of inward foreign direct investment to take advantage of the inauguration of the single market in 1992. It includes the worldwide growth of foreign investment dominated by information and communication technology.  The names of companies from this sector investing in the Irish State is a who’s who of the top multinational firms, including Intel, Gateway, Dell, AST, Apple, Hewlett-Packard, Siemens-Nixdorff, Fujitsu, Microsoft and Oracle. [The inclusion of an number of major pharmaceutical companies would be necessary to illustrate the extent of the presence of US multinationals today, including Pfizer, AbbVie, Johnson & Johnson, Novartis, AstraZeneca, Merck, Amgen, Gilead Sciences and Nuritas.]  The growth of the world market provided the platform and vehicle for the exports which powered the boom in the 1990s.  The deregulation of international capital markets helped fuel the boom and prolong its life through the first decade of the new millennium.

The transformative power of the boom, turned a relatively underdeveloped economy into one of the most developed but did not change the relative weakness of native industrial capital.  Despite unprecedented conditions for growth the indigenous sector did not develop the power to drive economic growth in the absence of foreign investment.(13)  To this extent the Irish State was still one dominated by the capital accumulation needs of foreign capital. (14) Combined with political weakness this constituted continuing imperialist domination of the country. It also demonstrated the impossibility of any meaningful ‘independent’ development of capitalism. [This was not possible in 2007 and is not possible now, all the more visible by the turn towards protectionism and more open imperialist division and rivalry, which has exposed the need for international alliances among even the largest capitalists states.]

Working class

All this has meant a huge expansion of the working class with the labour force increasing from 1,354,400 in 1991 to 2,027,900 in the first quarter of 2006, an increase of nearly 50%.(15)  Labour force participation rates have risen and immigration has increased.(16)  A significant section of the Irish labour force is now involved in very advanced manufacturing production, in sectors associated with higher than average profits, and therefore objectively with the potential to win gains for themselves and set a benchmark for those in other sectors.(17)  To some extent this has happened and real wages and living standards have increased, although this has had more to do with the natural propensity of the labour market to raise wages in a period of boom than any assertion of collective power by a working class labour movement.(18)

Once again, it is impossible to understand the Irish situation without placing it in a world framework and understanding international developments.  At this level globalisation has generally been viewed as undermining workers power and the gains that they have historically made.  It is also claimed that it will continue to do so in the future through a race to the bottom.

The ability of significant sections of capital to move to lower cost locations has weakened union bargaining power.  It has weakened the ability of states to tax capital and raise the corporate taxes that fund welfare provision from which workers are assumed to disproportionately benefit.

We will make a number of points about these arguments here but will not deal with all the issues thrown up.  Firstly, it is true that the power of the capitalist state vis-à-vis international capital has weakened.  This is demonstrably true and can be seen from the experience of even the most powerful state, the US, when it was unable for example to prevent ending the convertibility of the dollar into gold in August 1971.  This reflected the relative decline of the US economy and of the power of the US State to prevent it.  This does not demonstrate an end to the major contradiction between the increasing internationalisation of production and the predominantly national state system but signals its raising to a new level.  Nor does it ‘excuse’ the willing abandonment of national controls over the movement of capital which all states have legislated and enacted.  Nor does it mean that the repressive power of states is somehow less or that workers should support the strengthening of capitalist state power against international economic forces. (19)

The reformist perspective that laments the processes by which state power is weakened in the face of international capital leads only to nationalist ‘solutions’ (protectionism and anti-foreigner proposals sometimes dressed up as progressive measures), which would inevitably line up the workers of one group of countries against those of another group, and two world wars in the last century testify to the fateful consequences of this sort of policy.

State sovereignty has been weakened, most in the smallest countries – although they had least already, but this does not explain the weakening of the workers movement worldwide, only the weakening of the bureaucracies that lead the national labour movements and which have relied on incorporation into their state for their privileged position.  They are no longer able to deliver significant reforms, at least partly because the states that they rely on to deliver them do not have the same freedom of manouevre to accommodate them.  The major reason however is trade unions’ growing weakness over the last number of decades. (20)

A third part of the explanation for the weakening of the working class movement at a world level is the introduction of new technology and work practices that make it harder to organise workers.  These include new human resource management techniques including union busting; the growth of outsourcing and especially agency employment; subcontracted work; smaller scale employment sites and growth of temporary employment.

At a world level the opening up of China and India to multinational capital and the increased mobility of capital generally has created, or at least created movement towards, a world labour market – depressing the wages of the least skilled especially in the most developed countries, in effect the mobilisation of a world reserve army of labour.  This is reflected in pressure to lower costs in the most developed countries and/or to recruit cheaper immigrant labour.  In less developed countries it is reflected in huge migration to cities and the ending of non-wage sources of income that shielded the poor from the worst aspects of wage slavery and gave them some independence in relationship to capital.

All these trends are reflected in a falling share of wages within the economy. (21)  It nevertheless still remains the case that around 74% to 86% of world inequality arises from between country inequalities rather than within country inequalities. (22)  There thus exists a long way to go before the world working class faces roughly similar conditions which might help ground a common consciousness of its enemy and common terrain for fighting it.

Notes:

(13) The share of low-tech employment in indigenous industry is 74% while it is only 24% in foreign owned industry.  The share of high-tech employment in indigenous industry in 10% while it is 56% in foreign owned industry. ‘The average foreign firm operating in Ireland exports 92% of gross output, compared with the indigenous average of 31% . . . Indigenous industry remains almost as strongly excluded from the high-tech sectors as it was in 1974.’ ‘Multinational Firms in the World Economy.’ G B Navaretti and A J Venables p. 202 & 203.  See also the judgment of Frank Barry: ‘The structural weaknesses of indigenous industry manifest themselves across numerous dimensions. . . If Ireland’s foreign-owned sector were to be decimated for any reason, much of the economic progress made over the boom period could well disappear along with it.’ Op cit p. 8-9.

(14) Inward stocks of FDI as a percentage of GDP grew from 71.5% in 1990 to 129.7% in 2003 while the average for the EU15 was 10.9% in 1990 and 32.8% in 2003. European Economy No. 6 2005, European Commission, p. 399.

(15) ‘Population and Labour Force Projections 2006-2036, Central Statistics Office.

(16) The employment rate has increased from 53.9% in 1983 to 65% in 2003.  ‘Employment Miracles’, U Becker & H Schwartz (eds.) p 12. Foreign born as a percentage of the population in the Irish State has grown from 6.1% in 1991 to 10.4% in 2002 and the inflow of non-Irish has increased officially by 150,000 in the three years after 2002, CSO. [Eurostat data indicates as of 2025 that approximately 23.3% of the Irish state’s resident population was foreign-born, or 1.267m.]

(17) The rate of return on US FDI in 1997 was 27.2% in the Irish State, 11.9% in Europe and 13% elsewhere. For chemicals the rates were 35.4%, 12.6% and 12.8% and for electrical and electronic equipment 35.5%, 15.6% and 14.4%. ‘Employment Miracles’, op cit p 144.

(18) The standardized unemployment rate has fallen from 13.4% in 1990 to 4.4% in 2006 while that of the OECD group of countries as a whole has remained comparatively stable – 6.1% in 1990 and 6% in 2006, OECD Employment Outlook 2007, OECD, p. 245.  Real compensation of employees per head has increased by 1.6% per year between 1992 and 1996, 0.8% per year between 1997 and 2001 and 2.1% between 2002 and 2006. European Economy No.5 2006, European Commission, p. 143.

(19) A near example of the relationship between these two forces is given by Renault, the state owned car company in France, which implemented massive cuts through manipulation of competition between its French and Spanish plants with the object of reducing French workers terms and conditions. ‘Global Restructuring and the Power of Labour’, Bill Dunn, p. 76.

(20) Trade union density has fallen in most countries and in some over a long period.  In the 1950s US density was one third of wage and salary earners, in 2000 it was 13%.  In Canada union density dropped from 34.6% in 1985 to 30% in 2000.  In the EU it fell from 37.3% in 1985 to 29.5% in 1997.  In Korea it fell from 21% in 1980 to 11.6% in 2002. In Australia it declined from 40.5% in 1990 to 23.1% in 2002, from ‘Global Industrial Relations’ Edited by M J Morley, P Gunnigle and D G Collings. It is important to have some clarity over what this indicates – trends in organisation – rather than absolute measures of organisation, strength or militancy, because the coverage of collective agreements can be much wider than union membership. Bill Dunn, op.cit. p. 162.  More importantly in France, where union density is 9% – much lower than for example the UK or Ireland, where it is 29% and 45% respectively, workers have engaged in huge strikes which have successfully defended their conditions and rights in sharp contrast to either of the latter two countries.  ‘Global Industrial Relations’ op. cit. p. 74.  Northern Ireland has the highest union density in the UK but nowhere in that state system is the working class more bitterly divided and weak.

(21) The adjusted wage share of the total economy (measured as the compensation per employee as a percentage of GDP at factor cost per person employed) fell for the EU15 from 74.5% in 1971-80 to 67.3% in 2001-2007. K Allen in ‘Contemporary Ireland  a Sociological Map’ edited by S O’Sullivan, p 244. See also the graphs in chapter 5 ‘World Economic Outlook, April 07’ IMF quoted above.

(22) Quoted in B J Silver, ‘Forces of Labour: Workers’ Movements and Globalisation since 1870’ p. 10.

Back to part 1

Forward to part 3

What sort of Economy?  What sort of working class? (1 of 5)

The following article is one of five which are slightly edited versions of an article published on the Socialist Democracy website in November 2007, almost twenty years ago, just before the dramatic downfall of the ‘Celtic Tiger’ and the worldwide financial crash. It is republished here, with some slight edits, just as the economy of the Irish State is again booming for similar, if not identical, reasons and with some in the financial press anticipating another crash. The debate on the left in Ireland has moved on and some remarks on it will be made in the final part of the series.

*            *            *

Why is it important to understand what sort of economy exists in Ireland?

There are at least two answers to this.  Firstly the nature of the economy determines to a great extent the nature of the working class and plays a very important role in determining how that class thinks of itself.  Secondly the character of an economy is an obvious important starting point for any project for a socialist alternative and how that might be constructed.  This talk will focus on the first of these questions.

The economy of the Irish State is widely viewed as a success story and is held up as an example for other countries to follow. (1)  To answer the question – what sort of economy the Irish one is we can ask why it has been so successful.

One answer widely touted is that the Irish economy experienced a delayed catch-up with the rest of Western Europe.  Once policies of national self-sufficiency were abandoned and those of fiscal rectitude plus others were implemented the economy experienced the growth that was always possible.  The theoretical perspective informing this is that creating an environment for free market forces allowed them to combine to produce the growth that has occurred over the 1990s and to a lesser extent in this decade.  In this sense there was a certain amount of inevitability about such a process once the right policy choices by the Irish State were adopted. (2)

A second part of this explanation is that policies of low taxation, an educated and English speaking workforce, a business friendly environment and a helpful Irish State attracted the foreign direct investment that created the Celtic Tiger phenomenon.  There are differences among academics over the relative importance of the various elements but one objection is applicable to both.

The Irish State has pursued a policy of opening up to the world economy since at least the late 1950s. It has also offered tax incentives, a business friendly political and social environment and creation of an educated workforce since the 1960s.  Yet only in the 1990s did the economy take off.  In fact, in the 1980s the economy of the Irish State was in economic crisis, with most of the factors that supposedly led to success in place. (3)  It is not credible to argue that the growth of the 1990s and after was in any sense inevitable.

Explanation

It is quite clear that foreign direct investment by primarily US multinationals was the dynamic motor of the Celtic Tiger boom and is still the key foundation of current growth and success.  Decisions to invest in Ireland as opposed to anywhere else are obviously ones that require a global perspective.  It is therefore developments at the global level that must provide the starting point for any explanation of the development of the Irish economy.

This does not mean that domestic developments are unimportant, but they are secondary.  We have seen that similar policies resulted in different outcomes in the 1980s and 1990s and we can see that the key decisions – by multinationals to invest in Ireland – were taken outside the country.

One other consideration demonstrates this.  The open nature of the Irish economy (and others) has led to widespread emigration throughout the existence of the State up until the recent boom.  This has historically been determined by incorporation of the country into the British economy as a purely regional economy of the latter.  For most of its history the Irish State has effectively had no separate currency.  This has meant that it could not have industrialised in the 1960s in the way other less developed European countries did, such as Portugal, Spain and Greece, through production of low-wage consumer goods for export.  Wages could never fall low enough to allow this because workers would emigrate to Britain or even to the US before they did.  This is why the Irish economy had such a low productive capacity yet had relatively high living standards in world terms. (4&5) It also explains why recent growth could be so powerful and sustained, because untapped domestic reserves of labour (e.g. labour force participation rates) and external reserves of labour (including returning emigrants) could be deployed to keep it going.

To emphasise our point, what this demonstrates is that the Irish economy and its development has always been determined by external powers.  The much vaunted escape from the complete dominance of the British economy has been replaced by dominance from a combination of US multinationals and the Western European imperialist project of the European Union.

Bourgeois economists term all this as an example of a regional economy and point out that understood in these terms Irish growth rates have not been exceptional.  ‘If Ireland had been a US state its population growth in the 1990s would have ranked it twenty-third of the fifty US states, while no fewer than nine US metropolitan areas with populations of over 1 million grew faster than Greater Dublin.’ (6) The problem with this perspective of course is that the Irish State is a State and not a region and that this introduces elements into the analysis that a purely regional perspective could not allow.  For example, competition between the US and EU leaves the Irish State at the sharp end of any conflict and particularly riven by these conflicting forces. (7)

What all this demonstrates is that the internationalist politics of Marxism is vindicated from the start by the need to adopt an international analysis.

International economy

Following the Second World War international capitalism underwent an unprecedented boom accompanied by rising working class living standards.  By contrast the Irish State in the 1950s, in the middle of this boom, incurred acute balance of payments crises and massive and rising unemployment and emigration.

This world-wide boom was built upon defeats of the working class by fascism in a number of important countries and by incorporation and subordination in others; by a renewed wave of capital accumulation based on the physical destruction of much of fixed capital in the war, and the reduction in value of much that remained.  These factors combined to boost the profitability of capitalism which fuelled rapid accumulation on a new technological basis, including electrification and the car, and upon a new capitalist order based on US hegemony and the growth of world trade and investment.  By being inserted into the world market mainly through Britain, which was in relative decline, many of these factors did not apply to the Irish State.  By the time it had opened itself up fully to the world market the latter was approaching renewed problems of profitability.

The exhaustion of the technological changes that had initially propelled growth, rising working class demands, and reduced growth in productivity combined to reduce the rate of profit and thereby the rate of capital accumulation and economic growth.  This resulted in the economic crises of the late 1960s and 1970s. (8) The latter led to a severe economic crisis in the Irish State with the latter facing bankruptcy through a rising national debt and weakening of the foreign investment that had been attracted in the 1960s and 1970s.  In the 1980s significant parts of the indigenous capitalist base was bankrupted by outside competition with no offsetting increase in outside inward investment. (9)

The capitalist class reacted to the worldwide decline in profitability by attacking the working class and taking other steps to reduce costs by shifting production geographically and eliminating the least profitable companies so that overall capitalist profitability could be increased. (10) In this the capitalist class has been successful.

The Stalinist states of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe plus China have been reincorporated into the capitalist system (11), and the working class has incurred defeat after defeat in many countries symbolised most poignantly by the defeat of the yearlong British miners’ strike in 1984 -1985.  National liberation struggles were defeated, including in Nicaragua and Palestine, and the cause of socialism has been discredited in the eyes of millions of workers.  On the basis of increased levels of exploitation, increased availability of cheapened capital and new markets plus the application of new computer based technology the capitalist class has been able once again to increase profitability.(12)   This process has been described as globalisation, witnessing once again renewed growth of a financial sector that disciplines industrial capital and taxes the working class through expansion of debt, assisting the shifting of capital to more profitable locations. Defeat of the Soviet Union in the cold war has also allowed the US to once again seek to confirm a world hegemony upon which the rest of world capitalism may develop.  Its wars against Iraq are the most obvious manifestation of this new expansive role.

Notes

(1) Productivity in the Irish State was 29.2% higher than the EU average in 2005, being the second highest among all EU States, with a per capita Gross Domestic Product of 138.9 compared to an EU 25 average of 100 and ahead of the UK which had a figure of 117.5, ‘Measuring Ireland’s Progress 2006’ Central Statistics Office (CSO) p. 18. Of course GDP figures are grossly inflated by the reporting for tax purposes of economic activity in Ireland carried out elsewhere.

(2) See presentation by Patrick Honohan, TCD, 12th June 2007,’Ireland’s economic miracle: A story of delayed catch-up.’

(3) Unemployment reached a high of 17.6% in 1987; inflation reached a high of 20.4% in 1981; economic growth was negative in 1982 and 1983; the current budget deficit reached a high of 8.3% in 1986 and the public sector borrowing requirement reached 20.3% of GNP in 1981. Government debt rose to 129% of GNP in 1987, debt servicing reached 12.5% of GNP in 1985, debt servicing swallowed up 93.5% of income tax receipts in the same year; an average of 14,000 (net) emigrated each year in the first half of the decade and 27,000 each year in the second half – over 200,000 over the decade. ‘The Macroeconomy of Ireland’ Anthony J Leddin and Brendan M Walsh, second edition, pp. 20, 122 & 123.

(4) In European terms for example, in 1960 the EC average was 100 while the Irish State’s was only 60% of this while that of Greece was 39%, Spain’s was 59% and Portugal’s was 38%. ‘The Context of Economic Development’, Kieran A Kennedy in ‘The Development of Industrial Society in Ireland’, edited by J H Goldthorpe and C T Whelan, p. 12.

(5) In 1950 88% of exports went to the UK of which 80% were food and drink, ibid p. 11.

(6) ‘Future Irish Growth: Opportunities. Catalysts, Constraints’, Frank Barry, ESRI Quarterly Economic Commentary, Winter 2005, p. 3.

(7) An additional weakness is that regional models of growth argue that gains from the boom will be concentrated in the growth of asset prices, including property, because property and infrastructure are the only factors of production in ‘quasi-fixed supply.’  This however assumes what needs to be proved – why has their supply remained relatively fixed and why should it?  Has the growth in property prices reflected an imbalance between growing demand and less expansive supply and is the former not inflated by speculation?  Is not the real reason for this not tied to property rights, class structure and the traditional incentives in Ireland to make money from parasitic activities such as property ownership rather than in directly productive investment, despite the supposed transformation of the Irish economy and society?

(8) Average annual growth in GDP in the world fell from 4% between 1950 and 1973 to 2.9% between 1973 and 1996.   The net profit rate for manufacturing between 1950-70 and 1970-93 fell from 24.4% to 14.5% (US), 23.1% to 10.9% (Germany), 40.4% to 20.4% (Japan) and 26.2% to 15.7% (G7).’The Economics of Global Turbulence’, Robert Brenner, p. xxvii & 5.

(9) Permanent full-time manufacturing employment in Irish owned firms fell from 143,300 in 1980 to 110,918 in 1988 while those in foreign owned firms fell from 88,400 to 82,381.  ‘The Revival of Irish Indigenous Industry 1987-1997’ Eoin O’Malley,in ESRI Quarterly Economic Commentary, April 1998, p. 37.  It should be noted that this led to a number of workplace occupations by workers attempting to defend their jobs, e.g. Clondalkin Paper Mills.  This has not happened when multinational companies have folded.

(10) The geographical shift in production can be seen in the increase in foreign direct investment (FDI) over the past 15 or so years.  The outward stock of FDI in the world has increased from 1,791,092 million US dollars in 1990 to 10,691,889 million US dollars in 2005.  The stock of FDI as a percentage of GDP in the world has increased from 8.5% in 1990 to 22.7% in 2005.  The share going to the EU has increased from 37.2% in 1980 to 51.3% in 2005, of which the Irish State has received a disproportionate share. ’World Investment Report 2006’, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, pp. 7 & 303.

(11) That is their productive assets have become capital and their workers subject to capitalist exploitation and the production of surplus value– i.e. both have been employed to earn profit, as opposed to the diktats of a Stalinist plan upon which a bureaucracy enriches itself by more or less naked corruption.

(12) The US rate of profit rose from 16.4% in the first quarter of 1982 to 30.1% in the second quarter of 2007. .’The recovery in profit rates is the strongest in more than fifty years, with 15 successive quarters – until the second quarter of 2007 – of double digit profit growth, pushing profits to their highest levels since the late 1960s.’ ‘The SWP’s Economics’, ‘Permanent Revolution’ number 5, http://www.permanentrevolution.net.

Forward to part 2

The essential nature of the working class – Marx’s alternative to capitalism (84)

The self-emancipation set out in the previous post is a result of what the working is, what its essential nature is.  At the same time it is the result of struggle, including its struggle to become aware of its nature and the historical tasks that result from it.  It is not therefore a question of inevitability, as in a dictionary definition as ‘sure to occur, happen, or come’, or ‘unable to be avoided, evaded, or escaped.’

Inevitability here means that the essential nature of the working class, as set out in the last number of posts, entails that it will become to a greater or lesser extent aware of its interests, will struggle to defend its interests and will seek to create a society in which these become universal as society is transformed.  This potential can be realised because it is part of the essential nature of the working class, but this potential can be thwarted and destroyed so that the working class is degraded along with the universal interests it represents, entailing the equal degradation of society as a whole.

This view of the working class was expressed early in Marx’s political development when he stated that “Not in vain does it [the proletariat] go through the stern but steeling school of labour. It is not a question of what this or that proletarian, or even the whole proletariat, at the moment regards as its aim. It is a question of what the proletariat is, and what, in accordance with this being, it will historically be compelled to do.’

‘Its aim and historical action is visibly and irrevocably foreshadowed in its own life situation as well as in the whole organisation of bourgeois society today. There is no need to explain here that a large part of the English and French proletariat is already conscious of its historic task and is constantly working to develop that consciousness into complete clarity.”  (The Holy Family, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 4 p37)

This ‘life situation’ entails its lack of ownership of ‘bourgeois property’ – the means of producing what is needed to live at a certain standard of civilisation – and the results following of private appropriation of the results of its labour, appearing in the phenomena of economic and political crises, including war; also in the rampant inequality that disfigures and degrades relations between individuals and society as a whole.  The socialisation of this production under capitalism provides the basis of its transformation into the property of the working class who employ the means of production, which is the essential role of the working class.

Placed in this objective situation workers become aware of their existence as a separate class, although this in itself is not class consciousness of separate political interests, or how these must be advanced.  History demonstrates both this awareness, its striving for political expression, and the struggle to make it adequate to the tasks posed to it.  The latter is the struggle to marry the working class to Marxism.

The working class alternative thus arises from the objective nature of the class and the subjective development that arises from this nature, from the struggle to clarify its tasks and struggle for their achievement.  For Marx, socialists could assist in this task of clarification but not substitute its own clarity for it.  This required that they always seek to work and unite with the working class whatever its level of development, as put forward in the section of The Communist Manifesto entitled ‘Position of the Communists in Relation to the Various Existing Opposition Parties’.

‘Both for the production on a mass scale of this communist consciousness, and for the success of the cause itself, the alteration of men on a mass scale is necessary, an alteration which can only take place in a practical movement, a revolution; the revolution is necessary, therefore, not only because the ruling class cannot be overthrown in any other way, but also because the class overthrowing it can only in a revolution succeed in ridding itself of all the muck of ages and become fitted to found society anew.’ ” (The German Ideology, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 5 p52-53)

The organisation for which The Communist Manifesto was written was therefore to enable the development of this consciousness, including in the organisation itself, and Engels, in his History of the Communist league recorded that ‘The organisation itself was thoroughly democratic, with elective and removable authorities. This alone barred all hankering after conspiracy, which requires dictatorship, and the League was converted—for ordinary peacetime at least—into a pure propaganda society. These new Rules were submitted to the communities for discussion—so democratic was the procedure now followed—then once again debated at the Second Congress and finally adopted . . .’ (On the History of the Communist League, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 26 p321-322)

This attachment to democracy was a consequence of commitment to self-emancipation and in turn an obligation to base its politics on working class independence. This became a constant political struggle for Marx and Engels that continues today.  In a letter to Engels, on 18 February 1865, Marx denounced the idea that the Prussian government would help the workers set up their own cooperatives and excoriated even the idea that the working class should accept it: “the honour of the workers’ party requires that it reject such illusions, even before their hollowness is punctured by experience. The working class is revolutionary or it is nothing.’ (Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 42 p96). Dependence on the bourgeoisie or its state would make the working class a political nullity.

In this Marx was repeating something he had written eighteen years earlier in 1847 in respect of one German government when he wrote that ‘They delude themselves that the proletariat wishes to be helped, they do not conceive that it expects help from nobody but itself.’ (The Communism of the Rheinischer Beobachter, Marx, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 6 p96)

The import of this for today’s political struggle is obviously unclear to many.  It is why this blog consists not only of this series of posts on Marx’s alternative to capitalism but also statements on current political struggles, which so often criticise the wrong approach of others who profess to be Marxists.  It is written with the view that these mistakes are partly the result of ignorance of Marx’s views, or an assumption that some programmatic statements by later notable Marxists (or others) have in some way superseded what they said.  However these errors are most often the result of the import of alien ideas the force of which lie not in the ideas themselves but the social forces lying behind them, which often by their power seem to frame the political perspectives available.

Politics based on the independence of the working class does not mean subservience to illusions within the class or backward ideas that exist within it. Commitment to self-emancipation does not mean belief that the workers’ movement or its leaders will always be right and that their failures can be excused, minimised or accepted.  Marx was not afraid to stand against failures, mistakes or outright treachery within the workers’ movement and its leaders but this was not in order to detach himself from it, or seek an alternative to it, but to honestly express his views so that lessons would be learnt from failures, mistakes could be corrected and treachery expunged.  The workers’ movement is not short of any of these today.

From the failure of the Paris Commune in 1871 he wrote of ‘a decisive mistake in not at once marching upon Versailles’ by the Communards Central Committee; that ‘The communal constitution has been mistaken for an attempt to break up into a federation of small States’ due to ‘antagonism of the Commune against the State power . . . mistaken for an exaggerated form of the ancient struggle against over-centralization’.

Marx wrote of ‘Countless mistakes by the revolutionaries’ but he supported and defender the Commune even while he thought beforehand that ‘any attempt at upsetting the new government in the present crisis, when the enemy is almost knocking at the doors of Paris, would be a desperate folly.’  (The Civil War in France, Marx, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 22 p326, 333 & 509 and Second Address on the Franco-Prussian War, Vol 22 p269)

He summarised the action of the Communards by saying that the working class did not expect miracles from the Commune: ‘They have no ready-made Utopias to introduce par décret du peuple. They know that in order to work out their own emancipation, and along with it that higher form to which present society is irresistibly tending by its own economical agencies, they will have to pass through long struggles, through a series of historic processes, transforming circumstances and men.’  (The Civil War in France, Marx, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 22 p335)

When it came to treachery, he was also not afraid to take his stand: in one of Marx’s last political struggles against the political degeneration of the German Social Democratic Workers Party and its abandoning of independent working class politics, he and Engels stated:

‘As for ourselves, there is, considering all our antecedents, only one course open to us. For almost 40 years we have emphasised that the class struggle is the immediate motive force of history and, in particular, that the class struggle between bourgeoisie and proletariat is the great lever of modern social revolution; hence we cannot possibly co-operate with men who seek to eliminate that class struggle from the movement. At the founding of the International we expressly formulated the battle cry: The emancipation of the working class must be achieved by the working class itself.’ (Marx and Engels. Circular Letter. 17-18 Sept. 1879, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 45 p408)

Back to part 83

Self-emancipation of the working class

Karl Marx’s alternative to capitalism part 83

In The Communist Manifesto Marx and Engels stated that ‘the proletarian movement is the self-conscious, independent movement of the immense majority, in the interest of the immense majority.’ (The Communist Manifesto, Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 6 p495). They argued that ‘modern bourgeois society that has sprouted from the ruins of feudal society has not done away with class antagonisms. It has but established new classes, new conditions of oppression, new forms of struggle in place of the old ones.’

‘Our epoch, the epoch of the bourgeoisie, possesses, however, this distinct feature: it has simplified class antagonisms. Society as a whole is more and more splitting up into two great hostile camps, into two great classes directly facing each other – Bourgeoisie and Proletariat.’

This, however, is only one tendency of capitalist development, albeit the most important, in that capitalism has spread across the globe, ironically, as many who have considered themselves Marxists have argued the decisive importance of the obstacles to the development of capitalism (and therefore of the growth of the working class).  This has come in the form of the purported regressive effects of imperialism, set out, for example, in the ideas of dependency theory within which it is supposed to develop underdevelopment. Without this development of capitalism however there could be no talk of the proletariat becoming the ‘independent movement of the immense majority’ or of ‘society . . . more and more splitting up into two great hostile camps . . . Bourgeoisie and Proletariat’. 

If this were not the case then Marx’s view, expressed in The Communist Manifesto would not be correct; that ‘the bourgeoisie cannot exist without constantly revolutionising the instruments of production, and thereby the relations of production, and with them the whole relations of society . . . Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones. All fixed, fast-frozen relations, with their train of ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions, are swept away, all new-formed ones become antiquated before they can ossify. All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned . . . ‘

This constant revolutionising of the conditions and relations of production makes and remakes the working class, creating and destroying the material bases of its life, its organisation and its class consciousness.  As we noted in the previous post, it does not sweep away all previous ‘venerable prejudices and opinions’, which continue to weigh on the consciousness of the working class and oppressed, but develops new ones that are newly ‘venerable’ and sacred but equally inimical to the development of working class consciousness.  Politicised religion still plays an important role in many countries, including, for example, Christian fundamentalism in the US and Islamic fundamentalism in the Muslim world.  New theories of identity have been developed whose effect is to erase the importance of class and class struggle and divide the working class, often proposing impossible claims; for example that humans can change sex.

Marx and Engels grew up and matured when the process of worldwide capitalist development was beginning to create an industrial working class in only a few countries in the world and when this class was relatively small in some of them.  They never, however, broke from the central principle that the emancipation of the working class was to be achieved by the working class itself, even when its lack of development required alliances with other classes and forces in tasks that did not immediately and directly involve their full emancipation.  Had Marx based his politics on the worst oppression of the by far biggest class at the time, he would have advanced the politics of the peasantry. 

Engels noted that the proletariat, as it ‘evolved itself from these propertyless masses as the nucleus of a new class, as yet quite incapable of independent political action, appeared as an oppressed, suffering estate, to whom, in its incapacity to help itself, help could, at best, be brought in from without or down from above.’ (Anti-Duhring Part 3 Section 1 Historical)

After Marx’s death, and nearing the end of his own, he reviewed their joint experience, concluding that ‘the time of surprise attacks, of revolutions carried through by small conscious minorities at the head of masses lacking consciousness is past. Where it is a question of a complete transformation of the social organisation, the masses themselves must also be in on it, must themselves already have grasped what is at stake, what they are fighting for, body and soul.’

‘The history of the last fifty years has taught us that. But in order that the masses may understand what is to be done, long, persistent work is required, and it is just this work that we are now pursuing, and with a success which drives the enemy to despair.  (Engels 1895 Preface to The Class Struggles in France)

In this, he restated views that Marx had come to early in his political development in which he rejected the abstract universality of the state as simply the ‘political heaven’ of the atomistic individualism entailed in private property.  The state presents its members as ‘equal in their heaven of their political world, but unequal in their earthly existence of society’ (Contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Law, Collected Works Vol 3 p79). At this point in 1843 Marx had yet to identify the proletariat as the universal class and the means to end the alienation entailed by bourgeois private property, but he had already rejected the state as the means of doing so, ironic, as I have said so many times, that many of his self-declared disciples today take precisely this view.

His general approach at this time was set out as follows: ‘we do not confront the world in a doctrinaire way with a new principle: Here is the truth, kneel down before it! We develop new principles for the world out of the world’s own principles. We do not say to the world: Cease your struggles, they are foolish; we will give you the true slogan of struggle. We merely show the world what it is really fighting for, and consciousness is something that it has to acquire, even if it does not want to.  The reform of consciousness consists only in making the world aware of its own consciousness, in awakening it out of its dream about itself, in explaining to it the meaning of its own actions. (Letters from Deutsch-Französische Jahrbüche, Collected Works Vol 3 p144).

The politics that Marx and Engels developed did not therefore consist of moral claims that are ahistorical and forever categorical, or other timeless principles divorced from existing society; it did not comprise of virtuous panaceas or utopian schemes that should be imposed from outside, but were rather to be developed from the existing struggles and from within the society of which they were expressions.  Today, we might also add that it is not based on subjective experience, of the reaction of oppressed groups to their own oppression in, for example, various forms of identity politics, but in an understanding of their position within the relations of production and how their specific oppression is related to them.  From this their role in overcoming this oppression as part of a movement to transform these relations can be developed out of their own struggles.

‘All previous historical movements were movements of minorities, or in the interest of minorities. The proletarian movement is the self-conscious, independent movement of the immense majority, in the interest of the immense majority.’ Politics and struggle which is incapable of presenting such a perspective is incapable of promising emancipation.  Still less are those who, whether consciously or in effect, see other workers as the ‘privileged’, with their ‘privilege’ as the font of oppression, and therefore the enemy to be defeated

The first public statement of their general politics in The Communist Manifesto, as Engels much later explained, was therefore based not on a set of ready-made ideas, which instead they developed throughout their lives, but on the current reality and history of existing classes, struggles, and movements:

‘Yet, when it was written, we could not have called it a socialist manifesto. By Socialists, in 1847, were understood, on the one hand the adherents of the various Utopian systems: Owenites in England, Fourierists in France, both of them already reduced to the position of mere sects, and gradually dying out; on the other hand, the most multifarious social quacks who, by all manner of tinkering, professed to redress, without any danger to capital and profit, all sorts of social grievances, in both cases men outside the working-class movement, and looking rather to the “educated” classes for support.’

‘Whatever portion of the working class had become convinced of the insufficiency of mere political revolutions, and had proclaimed the necessity of total social change, called itself Communist. It was a crude, rough-hewn, purely instinctive sort of communism; still, it touched the cardinal point and was powerful enough amongst the working class to produce the Utopian communism of Cabet in France, and of Weitling in Germany.’

’Thus, in 1847, socialism was a middle-class movement, communism a working-class movement. Socialism was, on the Continent at least, “respectable”; communism was the very opposite. And as our notion, from the very beginning, was that “the emancipation of the workers must be the act of the working class itself,” there could be no doubt as to which of the two names we must take. Moreover, we have, ever since, been far from repudiating it. (Preface to the Fourth German Edition of the Communist Manifesto, 1890 F Engels, Marx and Engels Collected Works 27 p59-60)

Back to part 82

Forward to part 84

The scope of self-emancipation. Karl Marx’s alternative to capitalism part 82

2017 Women’s March in Washington, DC. (Flickr/Vlad Tchompalov)

Socialism is possible because of the socialisation of production through the growth of the productive forces.  Only one agent can accomplish this socialisation such that it is a cooperative and consciously planned development, and is the instrument of the actual producers themselves, the working class.  As these producers are the main productive force in the world the object of the process is the development of the producers themselves, of human development itself.

‘This appropriation is further determined by the manner in which it must be effected. It can only be effected through a union, which by the character of the proletariat itself can again only be a universal one, and through a revolution, in which, on the one hand, the power of the earlier mode of production and intercourse and social organisation is overthrown, and, on the other hand, there develops the universal character and the energy of the proletariat, which are required to accomplish the appropriation, and the proletariat moreover rids itself of everything that still clings to it from its previous position in society.’ (Marx & Engels Collected Works Vol 5 p88)

No other agent can carry out this endeavour, so that only the working class can abolish bourgeois private property through revolution.  This cannot be the more numerous (until very recently) peasantry; some combination of petty producers and peasantry; some combination of women, petty producers and peasantry or of oppressed nationalities, ethnic groups and races etc.  As such, these play no role in the existing relations of production such that they could create a new cooperative society.

As the oppressed their struggle against their subordination must transcend their particular oppression and only as constituents of the working class can they take hold of the means of production to transform class relations, end their own oppression and abolish exploitation.  Only acting as a class can they abolish class in general and rid the world of the material want that lies behind the social inequality of all kinds that provides the basis for continuing social conflict and oppression.  Divorced from class struggle their opposition to their oppression will not ensure its ending, while a class struggle that ignores their oppression cannot promise universal emancipation because the working class would not then be united as a universal class.

The working class is made up of many oppressed forces, including the female half of humanity, so that its struggles must embrace the specific interests of these oppressed groups in order that the working class is united, not as allies but as equal participants in self-emancipation.  Marxism provides the basis for the necessary unity that can overturn racism etc. and not just modify it, for example through equality of races among the capitalist class and elite layers of society, and within the working class itself.

We have explained in many previous posts how human productive activity is central to human development and is key to all social liberation – to the relations between individuals and cooperative control of society; to the growth and transformation of civilisation; freedom from want, removal of alienation and social inequality as the basis of social conflict e.g. sexual oppression and racism; and replacement by social cooperation, the creation of free time that allows for the development of each individual and the creation of a realm of freedom as the grounds of human flourishing.

From all this follows that the emancipation of the working class must be achieved by the working class itself – the bedrock principle of Marxist politics upon which all else is built. Marx even suggests that unlike previous revolutions in the form of private property, for example from feudal to bourgeois, the appropriation of this by the working class will be easier!

‘The transformation of scattered private property, arising from individual labour, into capitalist private property is, naturally, a process, incomparably more protracted, violent, and difficult, than the transformation of capitalistic private property, already practically resting on socialised production, into socialised property. In the former case, we had the expropriation of the mass of the people by a few usurpers; in the latter, we have the expropriation of a few usurpers by the mass of the people.’ (Marx Capital Vol 1, Chapter 32)

When the working class puts itself forward as the new ruling class it must make its interests the interests of the new society in general: ‘For each new class which puts itself in the place of one ruling before it is compelled, merely in order to carry through its aim, to present its interest as the common interest of all the members of society, that is, expressed in ideal form: it has to give its ideas the form of universality, and present them as the only rational, universally valid ones. The class making a revolution comes forward from the very start, if only because it is opposed to a class, not as a class but as the representative of the whole of society, as the whole mass of society confronting the one ruling class.’ (Marx & Engels Collected Works Vol 5 p60)

Marx goes on to say that ‘Every new class, therefore, achieves domination only on a broader basis than that of the class ruling previously; on the other hand the opposition of the non-ruling class to the new ruling class then develops all the more sharply and profoundly. Both these things determine the fact that the struggle to be waged against this new ruling class, in its turn, has as its aim a more decisive and more radical negation of the previous conditions of society than all previous classes which sought to rule could have.’ (Marx & Engels Collected Works Vol 5 p61)

In this way the struggle of the working class is more difficult.  We see this in the innumerable struggles of oppressed or subordinated groups who seek their own liberation or emancipation not as a part of this general movement of emancipation but as particular claims, separate and often opposed to the general and universal objectives of emancipation that lies within the working class struggle to abolish capitalism and establish socialism as the rule of the associated producers.

This is illustrated not only by the partial struggles against discrimination and domination that do not seek to go beyond equality within capitalism – of nations, races, and sexes etc. – but also of those supposedly class struggles, in reality economistic struggles, that determinedly do not go beyond particular claims within the bounds of capitalism.  Within the latter the universal (and political) character of the struggle of the working class is consciously rejected by typically reformist politics that nevertheless often presents itself as socialism.

It is no accident that these ‘pure’ working class struggles – over employment or higher wages etc. – often look not to the power of the working class but to the capitalist state as their saviour, so that the state is certified as the universal representative of society; against which proposition Marx began his search for an alternative that became his journey to working class emancipation.  This tendency, existing as a function of capitalism and the state itself, was enormously strengthened by the history of the working class movement. As Marx noted in The Communist Manifesto The proletariat goes through various stages of development . . . If anywhere they unite to form more compact bodies, this is not yet the consequence of their own active union, but of the union of the bourgeoisie, which class, in order to attain its own political ends, is compelled to set the whole proletariat in motion, and is moreover yet, for a time, able to do so. At this stage, therefore, the proletarians do not fight their enemies, but the enemies of their enemies . . .’

The development of capitalism has demonstrated that this subordination of the working class, and its movement, to the bourgeoisie is repeated again and again.  On the war in Ukraine, for example, many ‘socialists’ have lined up behind their bourgeoisie and state on behalf of the cause of one of its constituent allies (Ukraine) on the basis of fighting the enemy (Russia) of its purported enemy (its own bourgeoisie.)

The underdevelopment of the working class led to the early attempts to establish a socialist society failing and inevitably falling back on the state in circumstances in which the class was a minority and only the state could impose any sort of ‘universality’, as in the direction of society and the bending of social and economic arrangements to achieve it.  This is the summary story of the Russian revolution and the ‘model’ of state socialism that it proclaimed, and which further contributed to the view of the state as the carrier of the universal interests of the working class.

These became the ‘digressions, the temporary and local aberrations’ that Engels mentioned the day after Marx died, which were ‘inevitable’ but which, upon his death, ‘will now proliferate.’  And proliferate they have. Even the most radical interpretations of the first state-wide attempt to create a new socialist society often fail to recognise the lesson that it is not even a healthy workers’ state that will avoid the bureaucratic deformities and degeneration experienced and then celebrated as Stalinism.  It is the working class directly controlling society’s social and economic arrangements with the role of the state to defend them – not constitute them – that will do so.

Capitalism involved the general destruction of feudal and other constraints that rendered people unfree not only socially but also legally so that in both ways they were bereft of individuality.  It permitted the idea of individual freedom and thus the idea of its realisation, even if its social arrangements effectively circumscribed it and strangled its development.  It has shown that it cannot yet eradicate all ‘the ancient and venerable prejudices and opinions’ inherited from previous medieval societies that Marx proclaimed in his sweeping anticipatory judgement in The Communist Manifesto.

It also, however, created the grounds not only for the perpetuation of various forms of existing social oppression but also the possibility of recognising them and struggling against them.  This is the basis for new ideologies and movements of oppressed groups that realise that the possibility for ending their oppression now exists.  In themselves they have no universal aims because they seek only sectional liberation, but their existence not only implies that the universal emancipation promised by the working class must account for them but that it must encompass them or the emancipation that the latter claims is not universal.

Back to part 81

Forward to part 83

The grounds for the achievement of universal emancipation       

Part 81 of Karl Marx’s alternative to capitalism.

The abolition of capitalism and the social revolution that would make society the expression of the needs of the majority would quickly and radically start to reduce inequality and alienation.  This would be the result of the relations of production between individuals being transformed from class relations of exploitation to cooperative relations between individuals.  It would eliminate the material basis for the huge inequality arising from the monopoly ownership of productive resources that skews production and consumption on behalf of the capitalist class, while it would allow production to be directly planned for the needs of the majority.

This control would begin to eliminate the alienation that exploitation, atomisation and lack of solidarity create while developing the bonds of cooperation based on the basis of a cooperative economy that allows the conscious determination of social priorities.  Reducing material inequality through creation of mechanisms that enable everyone to engage in setting future needs would reduce social alienation and antagonism upon which social problems and certain patterns of individual harmful behaviour are created.

In this context the division of the working class, now no longer a class but a society of associated producers, would no longer have any interest in division and conflict based on race or nationality or any other particular individual attribute that is irrelevant to the cooperative solidarity of society.  The development of the forces of production that will erode and then erase inequality will be the product of associated producers for whom race, nationality, sex or sexual orientation etc. will not be socially or politically relevant. 

Inequality will not be abolished all at once, as the forces and relations of production develop but remain insufficient and the effects of capitalism on the consciousness of the working class persist, with its quota of ignorance and prejudice.  However, the working class/associated producers will no longer have the same material interests in reproducing the oppressive divisions that currently exist and which the existence of a capitalist class and its state foment.

All this is not the product of the creation of a preconceived ideal society but will be a process created by revolution through which many of the best characteristics of solidarity must already have been created for such a revolution to be achieved.  The social revolution required is a transformative leap, in which the achievement of political power is the decisive enabler, but it is not one without necessary prior development or with continued evolution thereafter.

In the Preface to a contribution to the Critique of Political Economy Marx wrote that ‘The totality of these relations of production constitutes the economic structure of society, the real foundation, on which arises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite forms of social consciousness. The mode of production of material life conditions the general process of social, political and intellectual life.’  Engels also wrote that the abolition of classes will also make possible “a really human morality which stands above class antagonisms and above any recollection of them.” (Anti-Duhring)

The creation of a cooperative economy will thus be the basis for the transformation of all of society including the mass consciousness that will arise from it.  Not only will economic and social inequality and oppression be eroded and erased, but the state as a mechanism of force and oppression will suffer the same fate as its useful society-wide functions become those of society itself, now governed and controlled by the associated producers.  Upon this basis reactionary ideas can recede and shrivel along with the oppressive behaviours they express. 

The continued existence of capitalism limits and impedes richer forms of individual self-realisation and higher forms of social development.  The unfettering of the forces of production will spur the more or less rapid transformation of the current stunting division of labour, including the division between those who make decisions and those subject to them.  Engels argued that removing capitalist relations of production would ‘secure for every member of society . . . an existence not only fully sufficient materially, and becoming day by day more full, but an existence guaranteeing to all the free development and exercise of their physical and mental faculties”

No other element, section or part of society can institute new relations of production that have the potential to abolish class exploitation and oppression, reduce material inequality and develop the forces of production in a way that can permit this free development, whether this be increased consumption, the protection of humanity from climate change, freedom from “non-class” oppression, increased healthy longevity, cultural development, or free time to pursue individual ambitions.  To the greatest degree the decisive force of production is the working class itself, and its development is the transformation of the working class by its own actions.

It would be obtuse to counterpose the rights of specifically oppressed groups – often misleadingly called minorities – to this perspective, for these ‘minorities’ consist of the majority of the working class, not just in world terms but in every society.  Socialism and the revolution needed to bring it about must be their creation, or it will not be at all.  It is hardly conceivable that particular needs within this majority will not be part of the objective of universal emancipation. The problem is not what the ending of class exploitation will do for women, people of colour, or the millions of poor in the world etc., but why this majority would not seek liberation and emancipation for themselves, as constituting the majority of the working class, through making this revolution and creating a new society.

Only through these ‘minorities’ liberating themselves can there be a united working class and only by a united working class can their liberation be achieved.  Domination and exploitation constitutive of “non-class” oppressions, such as those based on sex, race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, etc will not be ended within capitalism while the theoretical possibility that it could be would still leave them subject to all the domination and subjugation of their class compatriots.

That the majority of those subject to “non-class” oppression are working class or poor is illustration of the universal nature of the working class, and that the general erasure of inequality and reactionary consciousness is only possible under a cooperative socialist society is another.

That Marx did not develop a fuller understanding of the specific character of many “non-class” oppressions is no reason to believe that the working class emancipation he sought was for white men only.  This idea is absurd.  His championing of the struggle against slavery and his, and Engels, many comments on the oppression of women are testament.  When they speak of the free and full development of rich individuality this could not possibly be restricted to only some types of individuals.

The criticisms of what Marx didn’t write about women, racial subjugation and national oppression join a long list that includes finishing his life’s work Das Kapital; writing a book on dialectics; clarifying his ideas about what he meant by class; heading off future criticisms of ‘eurocentrism’ by developing his study of non-Western societies, and writing up an analysis of nationalism.  You could add to the list, but it wouldn’t get you any nearer to a decisive critique of him that you might seek to make.  Marx was notorious for missing deadline’s – wanting to read everything before committing to paper, but then, who knows what he would have come out with without doing so? One may as well ask why he didn’t have a more robust constitution and live longer.

The real point is not that Marx did not leave all the answers, as if new questions would not arise after his death, but that what is now referred to as his research agenda was good enough to open many questions and point to persuasive answers, and that these do not include a lot of the rubbish that some (many!) of his self-declared disciples have published later.

The relationship between “non-class” oppression and ‘the economical emancipation of the working classes’ as ‘the great end to which every political movement ought to be subordinate as a means’ is not settled by the above, and nor is the nature and scope particularly of women’s oppression, which we will come to later.  What the treatment above does is summarise the overall project of Marx and Engels that sustains their claim.

Back to part 80

Forward to part 82

Karl Marx’s alternative to capitalism part 80 – Universal Emancipation

We noted at the end of the previous post that the state and nationalism are held up as the instrument and ideology of society as a whole and that they manifest the individual’s general and universal interests and will.  Just as the UN’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights are the declared principles of today’s capitalist system so were the Rights of Man and the Citizen the banner of the bourgeoisie in Marx’s day.  Of course, states are national states and in competition with each other to varying degrees, while the state has its own interests and defends the class system on which it is based.  Its nationalism requires other states and their nationalism in order to make sense. The ideology of capitalism in general still appeals to rampant individualism, inequality and Adam Smith’s invisible hand, in which free markets create incentives for the universally self-interested to act unintentionally in the general interest. The claims of capitalism to represent general and universal interest are thus riven with contradictions.

For Marx, we have seen that the universal requirement to labour, and creation of the cooperative relations that develop the productive forces, are the grounds for universal development that must break through the limitations and restrictions of capitalism.  Having no property to defend itself (understood as the means of producing a livelihood) the working class has no interest in extending exploitation but rather only in collectively ending it.  This is the basis for abolishing alienation in general and rooting out the various forms of oppression that exist such as the oppression of women and of racial groups.

The rule of the working class can progressively end the injurious aspects of the division of labour and the alienation it engenders: the subordination of women through the sexual division of labour, and the international division of labour that is the product of imperialism.  This requires the working class to live and act as an international class, one opposed to national divisions, and itself the objective product of capitalist universalisation of exploitation, often labelled as ‘globalisation’.

In The Communist Manifesto Marx presented an alternative to other existing ‘socialisms’, which then existed and suffered from the ‘undeveloped state of the proletariat, as well as to the absence of the economic conditions for its emancipation’.  Two consequences of this were that existing socialist thinkers and movements appealed ‘to society at large, without distinction of class’ while ‘caring chiefly for the interests of the working class, as being the most suffering class. Only from the point of view of being the most suffering class does the proletariat exist for them.’

Today, when class struggles have inflicted a string of defeats on the working class, many socialist thinkers and movements have reverted to these early responses, with repeated setbacks hardening their conceptions which are then passed down to succeeding generations. So, we have the state as the (potential) representative of working class interests (through such things as ‘left’ governments) and socialism as the product mainly of a suffering working class (from economic crises, austerity, discrimination and poverty etc.).

Socialism, when it is considered at all, is now routinely presented as a response to oppression, with a more recent tendency to seek to sanctify the oppressed with the degree of suffering experienced and then to present responses specific to their particular claims and interests. Alternatives to the working class look to address the diversity of oppression through the varieties of those oppressed acting on their own behalf – at most with ‘allies’ or in ‘coalitions’ – by making advances through the state against discrimination and inequality. They do not start by seeking the unity of the working class to carry out the tasks Marx reserved for it while recognising that it consists of many of the elements of the various oppressed groups that have specific interests in addition to that of their class.

Historically it is not the most oppressed who create new societies, as Marx’s invocation of the history of class struggle in The Communist Manifesto illustrates:

‘The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.  Freeman and slave, patrician and plebeian, lord and serf, guild-master and journeyman, in a word, oppressor and oppressed, stood in constant opposition to one another, carried on an uninterrupted, now hidden, now open fight, a fight that each time ended, either in a revolutionary reconstitution of society at large, or in the common ruin of the contending classes.’ Yet, slaves, serfs and journeymen did not create new forms of society even as the old disappeared. Within capitalism, ‘society as a whole is more and more splitting up into two great hostile camps, into two great classes directly facing each other—Bourgeoisie and Proletariat.’

Classes other than the working class often suffer more than it, often individually or as a whole, but “of all the classes that stand face to face with the bourgeoisie today, the proletariat alone is a really revolutionary class’.  ‘The lower middle class, the small manufacturer, the shopkeeper, the artisan, the peasant, all these fight against the bourgeoisie, to save from extinction their existence as fractions of the middle class. They are therefore not revolutionary . . . they are reactionary, for they try to roll back the wheel of history.’

These classes develop ideas that typically permit them to understand society in a way most comfortable to their own role within it, not how they might be the creator of a new one, and justify their outlook in terms that assume and validate ‘common sense’ views, superficial appearances and prejudice.  Modern fractions of the middle class – professional layers or those whose job it is to produce ideas (writers, journalists, teachers and lecturers) can often develop sophisticated ideas that do not in the end challenge capitalism, never mind promise an alternative to it.

Reconstitutions of the middle class can produce newer versions of older petty bourgeois ideas, such as nationalism or fascism, with self-declared progressive responses often dressed up in confused manifestations of previous socialist programmes.  The absence of independent working class positions in their political programmes is the tell-tale sign that what is involved is purely petty bourgeois politics that eschews class struggle and gives primacy to the actions of the state.

‘The Communist revolution is the most radical rupture with traditional property relations; no wonder that its development involved the most radical rupture with traditional ideas.’ (The Communist Manifesto): ‘All previous historical movements were movements of minorities, or in the interest of minorities. The proletarian movement is the self-conscious, independent movement of the immense majority, in the interest of the immense majority. The proletariat, the lowest stratum of our present society, cannot stir, cannot raise itself up, without the whole superincumbent strata of official society being sprung into the air.’ (Marx and Engels Collected Works Vol 6 p 495)

It is a tribute to the continuing ability of capitalism to revolutionise its forces and relations of production that ideas promising a radical rupture are generated, which nevertheless do not challenge capitalism.  These ideas are often created in universities but reveal their non-threatening character by their rapid adoption by capitalism’s ideological apparatus, through television, newspapers, social media, publishing and big corporations, and most particularly in state bureaucracies.  These ideas have included complete and total opposition to any claim to universalism, often in such a total way as to be self-refuting, including opposition to the idea of truth itself.

Marx argued ‘that the economical emancipation of the working classes is . . . the great end to which every political movement ought to be subordinate as a means’ while most political movements today that view themselves as progressive have been set up with the belief that this is most definitely not the case. Many calling themselves Marxists unfortunately agree with them.  (Provisional rules of the Association Pp. 14–16 in Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, Collected Works, Vol. 20)

This was Marx and Engels view from some of their earliest writings to the last.  In the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Marx claimed that “the emancipation of the workers contains universal human emancipation” while in The German Ideology the revolution of the working class “leads to the abolition of . . . domination in general”. Towards the end of his life, Engels stated in the Preface to the 1888 English edition of the Communist Manifesto that “a stage has been reached where the exploited and oppressed class — the proletariat — cannot attain its emancipation from the sway of the exploiting and ruling class — the bourgeoisie — without, at the same time, and once and for all emancipating society at large from all exploitation, oppression, class-distinctions and class-struggles.’

In periods of reaction the social basis of many sections of the petty bourgeoisie leads them into reactionary politics, particularly those engaged with small capital such as farming or small business.  They often exploit themselves and are exploited by larger capitals, or consider themselves oppressed by the demands of the state, which ironically because of this is seen as their potential saviour. In their own way they suffer from capitalism and its socialisation into huge multinationals and monopolies but do not see these as harbingers of the alternative.

Under the rule of the working class majority smaller capitals will lose the unilateral power to exploit their workers – through their workers being able to join the majority of their class in working, controlling and managing their own workplaces; while the petty bourgeoisie will either cease to see their own class existence as small capitals to be to their benefit, or find that they are unable to compete with the larger worker-owned enterprises.  It is their strained existence under capitalism and the promise of a non-exploitative society that forms the basis for their social subsumption into the working class and the universal character of the emancipation that it promises them and others.

Back to part 79

Forward to part 81

Karl Marx’s alternative to capitalism part 79 – Universality (1)

In one of Marx’s earliest writings, the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right in 1843-4, he asks the question: ‘Where, then, is the positive possibility of a German emancipation?’

‘Answer: In the formulation of a class with radical chains, a class of civil society which is not a class of civil society, an estate which is the dissolution of all estates, a sphere which has a universal character by its universal suffering and claims no particular right because no particular wrong, but wrong generally is perpetuated against it; which can invoke no historical, but only human title; which does not stand in any one-sided antithesis to the consequences but in all-round antithesis to the premises of German statehood; a sphere, finally, which cannot emancipate itself without emancipating itself from all other spheres of society and thereby emancipating all other spheres of society, which, in a word, is the complete loss of man and hence can win itself only through the complete re-winning of man. This dissolution of society as a particular estate is the proletariat.’

The idea of universality and how it may be constituted is a central feature of Marx’s views, one that is acclaimed, as in the UN’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and also implicitly or explicitly rejected by supporters of identity politics, multiculturalism, postmodernism, religious fundamentalism, and nationalism etc.

The defenders of the rights of particular groups by virtue of their identity as being a member of that group are often in turn supported by those who would also proclaim support for human rights that are not based on these grounds.  No doubt many would argue their compatibility, but if the particular rights claimed by the former were such as to be merely expressions of human rights, then no particular rights would need to be demanded.

This is not primarily a problem of these particular rights not being wholly consistent with that of more general human rights, but of the reality of humanity being fractured and divided in reality.  The generality of human rights cannot recognise this so become an abstract moral claim that is continually eulogised and venerated but cannot be effected without particular claims being executed.

For Marx, it is the interests of the working class–the proletariat–that are compatible with and can bring about general human emancipation.  It is for this reason that Marxists do not cloak their politics in the language of human rights, because their enactment requires recognition of the grounds that would permit them and the struggle required to realise them.  Marxists are often dismissive of claims made on the grounds of human rights because they are made hypocritically by those who defend the grounds that necessarily impose oppression in the first place.  For Marx, the particular claims of the proletariat are universal ones because these include the abolition of itself, of the grounds of its particular oppression through the abolition of all classes.

The grounds for its particular claims must thus form the basis for the emancipation of all of society, and we have written about these extensively already.  In The German Ideology Marx writes:

‘This “alienation” (to use a term which will be comprehensible to the philosophers) can, of course, only be abolished given two practical premises. For it to become an “intolerable” power, i.e. a power against which men make a revolution, it must necessarily have rendered the great mass of humanity “propertyless”, and produced, at the same time, the contradiction of an existing world of wealth and culture, both of which conditions presuppose a great increase in productive power, a high degree of its development.’

‘And, on the other hand, this development of productive forces (which itself implies the actual empirical existence of men in their world-historical, instead of local, being) is an absolutely necessary practical premise because without it want is merely made general, and with destitution the struggle for necessities and all the old filthy business would necessarily be reproduced; and furthermore, because only with this universal development of productive forces is a universal intercourse between men established, which produces in all nations simultaneously the phenomenon of the “propertyless” mass (universal competition), makes each nation dependent on the revolutions of the others, and finally has put world-historical, empirically universal individuals in place of local ones.’

‘Without this, (i) communism could only exist as a local event; (2) the forces of intercourse themselves could not have developed as universal, hence intolerable powers: they would have remained home-bred conditions surrounded by superstition; and (3) each extension of intercourse would abolish local communism. Empirically, communism is only possible as the act of the dominant peoples “all at once” and simultaneously, which presupposes the universal development of productive forces and the world intercourse bound up with communism.’

Marx argues that these are the grounds for a real universality of freedom that previous ruling classes have proclaimed but could never represent:

‘For each new class which puts itself in the place of one ruling before it, is compelled, merely in order to carry through its aim, to represent its interest as the common interest of all the members of society, that is, expressed in ideal form: it has to give its ideas the form of universality, and represent them as the only rational, universally valid ones. The class making a revolution appears from the very start, if only because it is opposed to a class, not as a class but as the representative of the whole of society; it appears as the whole mass of society confronting the one ruling class.’

The character of the universality of the working class as the new ruling class lies in it being the working majority of society and in the nature of the appropriation of society’s powers that it will accomplish, based on the universal development of these powers, including the power of the working class itself:

‘Thus, things have now come to such a pass that the individuals must appropriate the existing totality of productive forces, not only to achieve self-activity, but, also, merely to safeguard their very existence. This appropriation is first determined by the object to be appropriated, the productive forces, which have been developed to a totality and which only exist within a universal intercourse. From this aspect alone, therefore, this appropriation must have a universal character corresponding to the productive forces and the intercourse.’

We should not pass without noting that when Marx speaks of the working class making a revolution, and of the universal character of this revolution, his interest is not in a uniform collective, one alien to the individual and her or his freedom.  For Marx, the abolition of classes is necessary to permit the freedom of the individual that capitalism and its liberal philosophy claims but destroys in reality.  After the previous passage he therefore goes on to say:

‘The appropriation of these forces is itself nothing more than the development of the individual capacities corresponding to the material instruments of production. The appropriation of a totality of instruments of production is, for this very reason, the development of a totality of capacities in the individuals themselves.’

How this is achieved is what constitutes working class politics, and is the realm of Marxism:

‘Modern universal intercourse can be controlled by individuals, therefore, only when controlled by all.  This appropriation is further determined by the manner in which it must be effected. It can only be effected through a union, which by the character of the proletariat itself can again only be a universal one, and through a revolution, in which, on the one hand, the power of the earlier mode of production and intercourse and social organisation is overthrown, and, on the other hand, there develops the universal character and the energy of the proletariat, without which the revolution cannot be accomplished; and in which, further, the proletariat rids itself of everything that still clings to it from its previous position in society.’

The concept of universality therefore has profound ramifications:

‘The individuals who rule in these conditions — leaving aside the fact that their power must assume the form of the state — have to give their will, which is determined by these definite conditions, a universal expression as the will of the state, as law, an expression whose content is always determined by the relations of this class, as the civil and criminal law demonstrates in the clearest possible way. Just as the weight of their bodies does not depend on their idealistic will or on their arbitrary decision, so also the fact that they enforce their own will in the form of law, and at the same time to make it independent of the personal arbitrariness of each individual among them, does not depend on their idealistic will.’

The state is today held up as the organ of the universal interest, as representing the interest of society as a whole.  There can be no more dreadful mistake, as not only does the state and the bureaucracy that it entails have its own interests, but these are bound tightly to those of the ruling class.  It is a mistake as common as it is egregious, proclaimed repeatedly even by those who claim to be followers of Marx.

As Marx notes: ‘actual private interests, etc., etc., are expressed as universal interests, descend to the level of mere idealising phrases, conscious illusion, deliberate hypocrisy. But the more their falsity is exposed by life, and the less meaning they have to consciousness itself, the more resolutely are they asserted, the more hypocritical, moral and holy becomes the language of this normal society.’ (All quotations from The German Ideology, Marx and Engels)

The one hundred and seventy-five years since Marx penned these words has witnessed hundreds of millions of deaths under the banner of universal interests in the guise of nationalism, the ‘national interest’ and wars for ‘human rights’.  At the same time the ideologues of capitalism have damned the explicit call for real universality as idealistic and totalitarian, if not actually impossible. Recovering the idea of universality as argued by Marx is therefore necessary but can only succeed if the politics of its creation through the working class is defended and advanced practically.

Back to part 78

Forward to part 80

Karl Marx’s alternative to capitalism part 78 – the importance of labour to universal emancipation

Behind the decisive importance of the development of the productive forces and the potential abolition of classes, which provide the grounds for the end of capitalist exploitation and social oppression, lies the fundamental importance of labour in understanding human society.

In the ‘Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts’, (Marx, in Early Writings, Penguin, pp. 279–400) Marx stated that ‘The whole of what is called world history is nothing more than the creation of man through human labour’:

‘The first premise of all human existence, and therefore of all history…[is] that men must be in a position to live in order to be able to ‘make history’. But life involves before everything else eating and drinking, a habitation, clothing and many other things. The first historical act is thus the production of the means to satisfy these needs, the production of material life itself. And indeed this is an historical act, a fundamental condition of all history, which today, as thousands of years ago, must daily and hourly be fulfilled merely in order to sustain human life.’

This is just as true today, although it would be an obvious mistake to see ‘production’ and the ‘needs’ it addresses purely in terms of the creation of goods and services necessary for bare minimum existence, or even in terms of modern ‘consumer society.’

What is consumed has to be produced:

‘Through estranged labour man not only produces his relationship to the object and to the act of production as to alien and hostile powers; he also produces the relationship in which other men stand to his production and product, and the relationship in which he stands to these other men. (Marx, Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts , p 279–400.)

Production thus involves not just the bare existence of humanity but also the form that human society takes, including the relations of production that set out the pattern of exploitation and oppression.  Upon this rests the superstructure of society, conditioned by the productive forces and relations:

‘. . . the real foundation, on which arises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite forms of social consciousness. The mode of production of material life conditions the general process of social, political and intellectual life. It is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence, but their social existence that determines their consciousness.’  We thus produce not just material (and immaterial) goods and services but also our social, political and ideological institutions, including philosophy, morality and religion etc.

So, when Marx talks about production and needs he is talking about the production of humanity itself, the form that it takes in various societies and the necessary interaction with the rest of nature, of which it is part:

“Labor, then, as the creator of use-values, as useful labour, is a condition of human existence which is independent of all forms of society; it is an eternal natural necessity which mediates the metabolism between man and nature, and therefore human life itself.” (Marx,, Capital, Volume I p133,). The satisfaction of human needs involves the ‘metabolic exchange with external nature’ (Grundrisse p. 528), which refers also to ‘historic needs … created by production itself, social needs’ (ibid p. 527), which are not just of a ‘physical’ nature (Capital Volume 1, pp 275, 341) but also include ‘intellectual and social requirements’ whose extent and number ‘is conditioned by the general level of civilisation’ (Capital: Volume I MECW Vol 35 p181.). 

It is in relation to this general level that individuals consider their own position, which makes inequality so corrosive of a person’s subjective and objective wellbeing: ‘our desires and pleasures spring from society; we measure them, therefore, by society and not by the objects which serve for their satisfaction. Because they are of a social nature, they are of a relative nature’ (Marx,Wage, Labour and Capital)

A number of consequences follow. The first is that the development of humanity’s productive powers create new needs, and human beings “distinguish themselves from animals as soon as they begin to produce their means of subsistence.”  “The second point is that the satisfaction of the first need . . . leads to new needs and this production of new needs is the first historical act . . . a certain mode of production . . . is always combined with a mode of cooperation” (Marx and Engels, The German Ideology, pp 42, 49, 50).

This form of cooperation can be understood in several ways. First, the organization of production is a historical process involving learning and tools that have been transmitted from one generation to another. Second, every previous historical form of production has involved some division of labour — division between mental and material labour, a gender division of labour, class divisions, racial and ethnic divisions, and a division which assigns different individuals to different tasks in the specific production process and in society as a whole.

Third, human consciousness, intrinsic to production, is itself social, as human consciousness is only possible through language, and language is inherently social. “Consciousness is, therefore, from the very beginning a social product, and remains so as long as men exist at all” (Marx and Engels, The German Ideology, p 51).

Finally, human production is fundamentally social because human beings are fundamentally social animals. As Sean Sayers puts it: “We are inherently and essentially social beings. We develop our natures . . . only by participating in society. . . . Sociality is inscribed in our very biology” . (Sayers 1998) What this means is not simply that we like to hang out with one another but that our very sense of individuality and the kind of individuality that we have depends on the form of society in which we live. “The human being,” Marx writes in the Grundrisse, “is in the most literal sense a zoon politikon [political animal], not merely a gregarious animal, but an animal which can only individuate itself in the midst of society” (Marx, Grundrisse p 84).

The Marxist understanding of humanity is thus that the ‘human essence is no abstraction inherent in each single individual. In its reality it is the ensemble of the social relations.’   These relations are conditioned by the need to produce socially: ‘In work, as we have seen, we produce not only goods but also social relations, and indeed we produce and transform human nature itself. ‘The whole of what is called world history is nothing more than the creation of man through human labour’ (Marx, Economic and philosophical manuscripts, p 400, 423).

In Engels’ ‘The Part Played by Labour in the Transition from Ape to Man’ labour is described as ‘the prime basic condition for all human existence, and this to such an extent that, in a sense, we have to say that labour created man himself.’

This creation is to be understood not just in terms of the need to produce in order to survive or to produce the culture we now currently enjoy, but also in terms of basic biological properties of humans that we take for granted and which developed from our evolution within the wider natural world.  This includes the development of cooperation and the necessity for language and the development of the specific configuration of the human brain, as the outcome of prior evolutionary changes in the corporeal configuration of hominids, eventually leading to the Homo Sapiens that includes opposable thumbs, bipedalism, binocular vision, etc. (Fracchia, The Capitalist Labour-Process and the Body in Pain, Historical Materialism 16, 2008: p 39)

This development is not, of course, the domain of Marxist theory, but of the natural biological and evolutionary sciences, but which Marxism has been able to build upon to explain the continuing development of humanity through its social organisation.  In terms of this development, Marxism perceives that humanity ‘by acting on the external world and changing it, at the same time change[s] his own nature.’ (Marx, Capital Vol. 1)

The development of the forces of production therefore can compel not only alienating labour but the source of what Marx considered real wealth: ‘when the limited bourgeois form is stripped away, what is wealth other than the universality of individual needs, capacities, pleasures, productive forces etc…. the full development of human mastery over the forces of nature, those of so-called nature as well as of humanity’s own nature? The absolute working out of his creative potentialities, with no presupposition other than the previous historic development, which makes this totality of development, i.e. the development of all human powers as such the end in itself, not as measured on a predetermined yardstick? (Marx, Grundrisse p488)

Central to this is the reduction of necessary labour time, which we explained in the previous post is: ‘that required to reproduce the working portion of society at its given, historically developed, level of subsistence, its standard of living.’  Its reduction allows in the free time made available:

‘The free development of individualities, and hence not the reduction of necessary labour time so as to posit surplus labour, but rather the general reduction of the necessary labour of society to a minimum, which then corresponds to the artistic, scientific etc. development of the individuals in the time set free, and with the means created, for all of them.’ (Marx, Grundrisse p 705–6)

While the potential exists for the time involved in surplus labour to be transformed into free time, the character of necessary labour time will also change.  The existing character of labour as mostly alienating, in which the social and cooperative nature of it is distorted and disfigured, could be transformed by conscious control of the productive forces to the objective of meeting and further developing human needs and powers.

‘I would have the immediate satisfaction and knowledge that in my labour I had gratified a human need, i.e, that I had objectified human nature and hence had procured an object corresponding to the needs of another human being’ (Marx ‘Excerpts from James Mill’s Elements of Political Economy’,Early Writings, pp. 259–78.)

‘Freedom in this field can only consist in socialised man, the associated producers, rationally regulating their interchange with Nature, bringing it under their common control, instead of being ruled by it as by the blind forces of Nature; and achieving this with the least expenditure of energy and under conditions most favourable to, and worthy of, their human nature. (Marx, Capital, Volume III p959)

The complete socialisation of the productive forces of society by the working class abolishing all classes, including itself, is a means, not of limited freedom from oppression – a purely negative objective – but ‘“the full development of human mastery over the forces of nature . . . the absolute working out of [their] creative potentialities . . . the development of all human powers as an end in itself ” (Marx, Grundrisse p488). Such is the claim of Marxism for the universal character of the working class struggle for emancipation.

Back to part 77

Forward to part 79